Navigating Canadian Property Law - An Overview
Every time a business is bought or sold, there is a change in property ownership. This could involve the conveyance of tangible property, like land, or intangible property, such as the brand name or trademark of the business. In this piece, we will delve into Canadian property law, providing a definition of property, exploring its various classifications, and shedding light on the legal rights linked to property ownership in Canada.
Understanding the Concept of Property
Property law consists of the laws and guidelines that dictate our relationship with items that can be possessed. Many people often view property as tangible assets such as equipment, inventory, or real estate. However, the legal understanding of property goes far beyond merely material goods that can be physically touched. Property can encompass more intangible aspects like the right to implement a particular industrial technique or the license to use a specific business name. Yet, it's important to note that not all valuable things that deserve protection are classified as property under property law. For example, although citizenship is an invaluable privilege, it's not a right that can be traded or sold. One of the responsibilities of property law is to clarify what constitutes property and what can be owned. Moreover, property law empowers owners to assert their rights over their property.
Types of Property
As society has evolved, so too have our systems of law, especially in the realm of property rights. This evolution has led to the categorization of property into distinct groups, each with its own set of legal implications and considerations. These categories help to structure our understanding of property and provide a framework for the rights, responsibilities, and protections associated with ownership.
Broadly speaking, property law is concerned with defining what can be owned, who can own it, and how those ownership rights can be transferred. Property can be categorized into several types: Real property, Aboriginal Title (a classification unique to Canada), and Personal Property, which can further be subdivided into tangible and intangible types.)
Real Property
Real property, often referred to as "immovable" property, pertains to land, anything permanently affixed to it, and the related legal rights. For instance, a crop growing in a field is considered real property until it is harvested and no longer connected to the land. Each province manages a thorough system for publicly recording land ownership and legal interests associated with it.
Aboriginal Title
The Canadian legal system acknowledges a special form of ownership related to certain lands in Canada that belong to Indigenous peoples. This interest, known as Aboriginal title, includes "rights similar to those connected with fee simple." These rights encompass the authority to determine land usage, the right to enjoyment and occupancy of the land, the possession of the land, the entitlement to the land's economic benefits, and the prerogative to actively use and manage the land.
Personal Property
Personal property encompasses all that is not classified as real property. It is divided into two primary categories: tangible and intangible.
- Tangible property refers to property that has a physical form. For instance, Cran-Terra, in its business operations, will procure sports and outdoor goods that aren't affixed to land or a structure. This type of personal property is legally known as chattels or movables.
- Intangible property, on the other hand, derives its value from legal rights instead of tangible, physical attributes. This includes insurance policies, accounts receivable, bank accounts, customer records, and various types of intellectual property like patents and trademarks. Internet domain names have also been acknowledged as a form of property. These types of assets are legally referred to as "choses in action." Despite being intangible, this form of property is no less real or significant than tangible property and, indeed, it fuels much of our contemporary economy.
Rights Pertaining to Property Under Law
In contrast to the United States Constitution, Canada's Charter of Rights and Freedoms doesn't include constitutional safeguards for property. Nonetheless, this doesn't imply that Canadian law offers no protections for property.
For instance, Alberta has implemented the Alberta Personal Property Bill of Rights, which parallels the Fifth Amendment of the 1791 Bill of Rights, in that it invalidates any provincial law that permits the Crown to acquire permanent title in personal property without incorporating a method for providing compensation for that acquisition. The Canadian Bill of Rights also establishes that Canadians are entitled to the "enjoyment of property, and the right not to be deprived thereof except by due process of law". However, this legislation only applies to federally regulated matters and can be superseded by any other act of Parliament. There is also specific legislation designed to safeguard certain forms of property. For example, intellectual property rights are protected by several federal laws such as the Patent Act, while privately owned land is shielded from arbitrary expropriation by provincial laws like the Ontario Expropriations Act, which also mandates that governments adhere to fundamental procedural fairness when expropriating private land. Many of our rights to protect our property are found in common law. For instance, the torts of trespass and nuisance safeguard a person's possession and enjoyment of land from interference, and the tort of passing off protects the goodwill associated with a business's products.
Property Law Relevance in Buy and Sell Transactions
Property law is fundamentally important in the processes of purchasing and selling businesses. At the heart of these transactions is the transfer of property ownership, which can encompass both tangible and intangible assets. Familiarity with the legal rules surrounding property rights is therefore important for ensuring that these transactions are completed efficiently and within the confines of the law.
Determining whether the sale is an asset sale or a share sale is important, given the distinct tax and legal outcomes associated with each. Our advice to clients is always to enlist the expertise of a seasoned business lawyer when attempting to execute a transaction. The process of buying and selling a business can be intricate, with potential challenges that could arise in the future.
Final Thoughts
Understanding the complexities of property law is important in navigating the business landscape, particularly when it comes to buying or selling a business. Property law in Canada encompasses not just physical assets but also intangible ones, including intellectual property and business licenses. The distinction between real property, personal property, and Aboriginal title, each with its unique legal parameters, underscores the importance of this legal field.
About the Author:
Roberts & Obradovic Law is a Toronto-based law firm specializing in mergers and acquisitions, corporate law, and business strategy. With a proven track record of assisting various businesses in successfully handling intricate transactions, the firm is committed to safeguarding their clients' interests. To find out more about their expertise and services, visit their website at https://robertsobradovic.com.
Opinions expressed here by contributors are their own.
BuyAndSellABusiness.com launched a private Slack community designed to help people connect, share insight and ask questions about buying, selling and growing businesses or franchises. Apply to join here.
Remember, if you are interested in receiving the latest business news, insights and opportunities from BuyAndSellABusiness.com, you can subscribe to our newsletter here. Also, if you are not a BuyAndSellABusiness.com user yet, what are you waiting for? Click here!
